I struggled with whether or not to celebrate Hanukkah this year. I absolutely did not want a replacement for Christmas. But I also did not want to miss out on a way to celebrate Yahweh in a way that would be pleasing to Him. After all Yeshua (Jesus) did travel to Jerusalem, to the temple, during Hanukkah, so that must mean He celebrated it, right? (John 10:22)
We ended up doing the antithesis of everything we had resolved to do.
My first course of action in anything I am unsure about, is to research. And that is exactly what we did. Our family read various historical accounts of the Maccabees, including the book of 1 Maccabees.
I also prayed for wisdom.
I first decided I was uncomfortable with the "Hanukkah Menorah" (sometimes called a Hanukiah) with its 9 branches, because it did not fit the Biblical description of the menorah (Exodus 25, Exodus 37). I decided if I was going to buy a menorah, it would be gold, have 7 branches and be as close as possible to the one in Scripture.
But then, as we read about the making of the holy articles for the Tabernacle, we learned that they were not to be used outside the Tabernacle, or by anyone but the priests. (Exodus 30:32, 37 and Leviticus 26:1 is a bit of a stretch, but it did influence our thinking as well.) We decided to skip the menorah all together.
Not to mention, in our research, we found there is no record of the "miracle of oil" ever occurring in any of the accounts of the actual miracles that occurred for the Maccabees. It is a tradition that has been passed down, with no historical backing.
Since we did not believe the "miracle of the oil", we would also be skipping the Hanukkah tradition of fried foods. No latkes or doughnuts.
But...as we were discussing our decision, my daughter became very curious about latkes. She wanted to know what they were. I explained, but her curiosity was not satisfied. So I pulled up photos, and then videos of how to make them, but she still was not satiated. We ended up looking up a recipe and making latkes after all, as an educational endeavor and not as an aspect of a Hanukkah celebration.
So why are there 8 days of Hannukah, if there was no oil miracle? I believe it comes from the example of Hezekiah in 1 Chronicles 29, when he also cleansed the temple.
We also decided to skip dreidels. According to our understanding of Scripture, gambling is not a way to glorify Adonai.
But....at church, there was a Hanukkah celebration, and since we were already there, and wanted to be included in the fellowship, we participated in the celebration, including games of dreidel. It was a lot of fun, and we thoroughly enjoyed it, but afterwards I struggled with guilt for going against our convictions.
Overall, in our readings about the Maccabees, I did find the message of this "holiday" to be exactly in line with what Yahweh has been doing in our lives this year.
To me, the Feast of Dedication (Hanukkah) is about following Yahweh's commands NO MATTER WHAT. It is about not giving in and following the culture, even if everyone else is doing it. The Maccabees and their followers were willing to fight and die, rather than do the things Yahweh calls abominations. They fought for liberty to follow Yahweh the way He commands us to, in His Word. And He blessed their obedience miraculously, by giving them victory, even though they were impossibly outnumbered and had everything against them.
I think we can all benefit from a time, each year, to remember that we must be set apart and holy to the Lord. (1 Peter 1:16, Leviticus 11:44, Leviticus 19:2) A time to rededicate ourselves to Him, and cleanse our own temples (1 Corinthians 6:19). To pray that He would show us ways we have been tainted by the culture around us, so that we can repent and turn away from those practices that grieve Him.